Season 8, Episode 14: "The Van Buren Boys"

Then they back me up against the cartoon map of Italy...

...and all of a sudden they just stop.

What? What happened?

Because I'm still holding the garlic shaker, like this:

I'm only showing eight fingers.

- Well, what does that mean? - That's their secret sign.

See, Van Buren, he was the eighth president.

They thought I was a former Van B Boy.